EU digital fairness proposal targets manipulative online design, but gaps remain
The European Commission’s proposal for a Digital Fairness Act aims to tackle dark patterns that manipulate consumers online. Christoph Busch, an academic at Osnabrück University in Germany who researches consumer law and digital services, reviewed draft leaks before the act was formally announced on Wednesday. He notes that existing legislation has limited scope, leaving consumer protection gaps in areas like web shops and online gaming.
Busch explains that dark patterns refer to manipulative design features that steer consumers in various directions. One example is ‘confirmshaming’, where a user declining insurance on a ticket website is asked, ‘Do you really want to carry the risk for you and your family?’ Such tactics are not fully addressed by current rules.
Targeted amendments needed
The Digital Services Act addresses online intermediary services, but the digital space extends beyond marketplaces and platforms. While the DSA covers recommender systems and advertising on platforms, web shops and various online gaming business models are not included. The EU Kids Act focuses on minors, yet addictive design features also affect adults, including gamification in online shopping.
Busch argues for targeted amendments to the existing regulatory framework rather than adding another layer. He says, “It is about getting the balance right,” noting that both consumers and businesses can benefit from clearer provisions as long as they are not too burdensome. The Commission’s proposal includes research on addictive design and subscriptions, reflecting years of study on dark patterns and engagement-maximising design. Busch believes it is time to translate those insights into regulation.
